Commentary
Local, place-based governance for net zero: a review and research agenda
Abstract
Net zero is widely perceived to be a societal challenge that cannot be addressed through business as usual but requires active governance aimed at societal transformation. In the UK, three quarters of all local authorities have declared climate emergencies, yet local action on net zero remains slow and uneven. Transforming local governance so that it is capable of organising to deliver change at a speed and scale commensurate with net zero targets is proving problematic. In this commentary the reasons why are explored. Using a narrative review method, informed by contemporary thinking on Transformative Innovation Policy, the commentary critically examines a growing body of knowledge on local, place-based governance of net zero, which has emerged at the interface of policy and practice in the UK since 2019. The review synthesises this evidence into seven place-based governance challenges and identifies extant obstacles and opportunities in navigating towards more effective governance arrangements. Collectively these challenges highlight the importance of organising to deliver change, not just organising the delivery of change, and the guiding role of the state in the process. The commentary concludes by setting out future research avenues.
Keywords
net zerogovernanceplace-based governancesocietal challengestransformative innovation policyCopyright statement
© The author(s) 2024. This is an open access article licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 International LicenseCite this article
McMillan, E., Barnes, J., Nolden, C. & McDermont, M. (2024), ‘Local, place-based governance for net zero: a review and research agenda’, Journal of the British Academy, 12(4): a47 https://doi.org/10.5871/jba/012.a47No Data Found
No Data Found
No Data Found
Young people worldwide are engaged in diverse forms of participation which offer a pathway for demanding accountability from governance actors. In contexts with fragile governance structures, young people face a unique set of challenges in their efforts to demand accountability or participate in decision-making. The expected relationship between participation and accountability as understood in liberal, democratic settings is often absent and instead demands for accountability are often made through strategies ‘at the margins’. Using Palestine as a case study, we show how young people look for accountability beyond state institutions and the national scale, using diverse strategies depending on their embedded position in society. This analysis sheds light on the complex reality of youth participation and accountability mechanisms in socially, politically and physically contested spaces and, by extension, points towards challenges and opportunities in implementing the Sustainable Development Goals.
The prevailing approach of policymakers to the design and delivery of net zero business support remains focused on financial economic growth. This approach limits the role of businesses in leading societal transformation towards a sustainable future. Although opportunities for businesses to transform so that they remain financially viable and resilient may emerge, support and policy innovation are needed to enable businesses to navigate the net zero transition. Place-based policies are one way of ensuring localities, cities and regions respond effectively to the economic and social challenges of the transition. Despite place being identified as one of five foundations of national and local industrial strategies, business support provision across the regions remains largely ‘place-blind’. Support programmes are often generic in their design, scope and delivery mechanisms, and downplay the challenges businesses face when engaging with the net zero transition. This article critically reviews the policy articulation and the state of net zero business support from the place-based perspective. By applying place–policy–practice nexus thinking, gap analysis of net zero support is undertaken, and resolutions are offered. The article calls for a deeper reflection of place characteristics in policy discourse, local strategies and policy mixes. This requires concerted efforts from the government, support agencies, universities and businesses to develop a shared understanding of the growth opportunities and risks of the net zero transition relative to place. This includes the development of representative net zero governance mechanisms and addressing the growing demand for net zero skills.
